{ "generated_at": "2026-05-20T14:35:11", "theme": "AI", "center_strategy": { "short": "short_hybrid_05", "long": "long_hybrid_05" }, "row_count": 68, "coverage": [ { "period": "2023", "horizon": "short", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 9, "status": "완료" }, { "period": "2023", "horizon": "long", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 9, "status": "완료" }, { "period": "2024", "horizon": "short", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 9, "status": "완료" }, { "period": "2024", "horizon": "long", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 9, "status": "완료" }, { "period": "2025", "horizon": "short", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 9, "status": "완료" }, { "period": "2025", "horizon": "long", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 7, "status": "완료" }, { "period": "2026Q1", "horizon": "short", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 9, "status": "완료" }, { "period": "2026Q1", "horizon": "long", "has_center_multi_agent": true, "has_deterministic": true, "has_rsi": true, "has_bollinger": true, "row_count": 7, "status": "완료" } ], "summary": [ { "period": "2023", "horizon": "short", "center_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": 14.92, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_short", "deterministic_return_pct": 13.58, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "rsi_ranked", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": 15.15, "best_technical_strategy": "rsi_ranked", "best_technical_return_pct": 15.15, "winner_strategy": "rsi_ranked", "winner_group": "technical", "winner_return_pct": 15.15, "verdict": "mixed" }, { "period": "2023", "horizon": "long", "center_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": -0.42, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_long", "deterministic_return_pct": 7.64, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": 52.69, "best_technical_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "best_technical_return_pct": 52.69, "winner_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "winner_group": "technical", "winner_return_pct": 52.69, "verdict": "multi_agent_lagged" }, { "period": "2024", "horizon": "short", "center_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": 46.99, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_short", "deterministic_return_pct": 38.27, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": 167.72, "best_technical_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "best_technical_return_pct": 167.72, "winner_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "winner_group": "technical", "winner_return_pct": 167.72, "verdict": "mixed" }, { "period": "2024", "horizon": "long", "center_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": 0.08, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_long", "deterministic_return_pct": 16.78, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "bollinger_lower", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": 7.11, "best_technical_strategy": "vol_adjusted_momentum", "best_technical_return_pct": 16.02, "winner_strategy": "deterministic_long", "winner_group": "deterministic", "winner_return_pct": 16.78, "verdict": "multi_agent_lagged" }, { "period": "2025", "horizon": "short", "center_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": 190.16, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_short", "deterministic_return_pct": 216.92, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": 49.81, "best_technical_strategy": "momentum_20d", "best_technical_return_pct": 60.08, "winner_strategy": "deterministic_short", "winner_group": "deterministic", "winner_return_pct": 216.92, "verdict": "mixed" }, { "period": "2025", "horizon": "long", "center_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": 103.29, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_long", "deterministic_return_pct": 82.78, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "rsi_ranked", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": 94.71, "best_technical_strategy": "rsi_ranked", "best_technical_return_pct": 94.71, "winner_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "winner_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "winner_return_pct": 103.29, "verdict": "multi_agent_best_or_tied" }, { "period": "2026Q1", "horizon": "short", "center_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": 15.4, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_short", "deterministic_return_pct": 24.62, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "rsi_oversold", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": 8.55, "best_technical_strategy": "rsi_oversold", "best_technical_return_pct": 8.55, "winner_strategy": "deterministic_short", "winner_group": "deterministic", "winner_return_pct": 24.62, "verdict": "mixed" }, { "period": "2026Q1", "horizon": "long", "center_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "center_return_pct": 14.2, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "deterministic_strategy": "deterministic_long", "deterministic_return_pct": 6.14, "best_rsi_bollinger_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "best_rsi_bollinger_return_pct": -8.58, "best_technical_strategy": "bollinger_ranked", "best_technical_return_pct": -8.58, "winner_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "winner_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "winner_return_pct": 14.2, "verdict": "multi_agent_best_or_tied" } ], "artifacts": { "csv": "/Users/leedohoun/Desktop/HQA_Project/experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/comparison_table/multi-agent-centered-comparison.csv", "json": "/Users/leedohoun/Desktop/HQA_Project/experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/comparison_table/multi-agent-centered-comparison.json", "report": "/Users/leedohoun/Desktop/HQA_Project/experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/comparison_table/multi-agent-centered-comparison.md", "coverage_audit": "/Users/leedohoun/Desktop/HQA_Project/experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/BACKTEST_COVERAGE_AUDIT.md", "main_report": "/Users/leedohoun/Desktop/HQA_Project/experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/AI_STRATEGY_COMPARISON_REPORT.md" }, "rows": [ { "period": "2023", "source_period": "validation_2023", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 14.92, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": 17.86, "mdd_pct": -17.34, "sharpe": 0.99, "win_rate_pct": 33.33, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 45.45, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2023-short_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "validation_2023", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 8.57, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": 11.51, "mdd_pct": -13.17, "sharpe": 0.69, "win_rate_pct": 28.57, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 45.45, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2023-short_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -6.35, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -6.35, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 4.17, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "validation_2023", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "deterministic_short", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Short deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 13.58, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": 16.52, "mdd_pct": -17.34, "sharpe": 0.92, "win_rate_pct": 33.33, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 48.48, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2023-deterministic_short.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -1.34, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -1.34, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 9, "position_count": 27, "total_return_pct": -4.18, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": -1.24, "mdd_pct": -33.18, "sharpe": 0.07, "win_rate_pct": 14.29, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2023-rsi_oversold-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -19.1, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -19.1, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -15.84, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 21, "position_count": 63, "total_return_pct": 15.15, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": 18.09, "mdd_pct": -43.1, "sharpe": 0.8, "win_rate_pct": 47.62, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 39.68, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2023-rsi_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.23, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.23, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -25.76, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": -4.56, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": -1.62, "mdd_pct": -6.74, "sharpe": -0.79, "win_rate_pct": 9.52, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2023-bollinger_lower-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -19.48, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -19.48, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 10.6, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 21, "position_count": 63, "total_return_pct": -8.17, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": -5.23, "mdd_pct": -32.5, "sharpe": -0.27, "win_rate_pct": 47.62, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 39.68, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2023-bollinger_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -23.09, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -23.09, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -15.16, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "momentum_20d", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Highest 20-day momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 21, "position_count": 63, "total_return_pct": -5.88, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": -2.94, "mdd_pct": -42.53, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 52.38, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 49.21, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2023-momentum_20d-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -20.8, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -20.8, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -25.19, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "vol_adjusted_momentum", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Volatility-adjusted momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 21, "position_count": 63, "total_return_pct": -34.79, "benchmark_return_pct": -2.94, "excess_return_pct": -31.86, "mdd_pct": -44.43, "sharpe": -1.81, "win_rate_pct": 38.1, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 42.86, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2023-vol_adjusted_momentum-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.92, "center_excess_return_pct": 17.86, "center_mdd_pct": -17.34, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -49.71, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -49.72, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -27.09, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "validation_2023", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": -0.42, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": -31.49, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": -0.03, "win_rate_pct": 40.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 22.22, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2023-long_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "validation_2023", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": -9.94, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": -41.02, "mdd_pct": -8.11, "sharpe": -0.82, "win_rate_pct": 20.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 11.11, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2023-long_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -9.52, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -9.53, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.11, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "validation_2023", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "deterministic_long", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Long deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": 7.64, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": -23.43, "mdd_pct": -3.34, "sharpe": 0.42, "win_rate_pct": 20.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2023-deterministic_long.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 8.06, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 8.06, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -3.34, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 0, "position_count": 0, "total_return_pct": 0.0, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": -31.08, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 0.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "status": "completed_no_trade", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2023-rsi_oversold-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.42, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.41, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": 50.39, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": 19.31, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 1.23, "win_rate_pct": 40.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 77.78, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2023-rsi_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 50.81, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 50.8, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 0, "position_count": 0, "total_return_pct": 0.0, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": -31.08, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 0.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "status": "completed_no_trade", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2023-bollinger_lower-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.42, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.41, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": 52.69, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": 21.62, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 1.3, "win_rate_pct": 60.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 88.89, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2023-bollinger_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 53.11, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 53.11, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "momentum_20d", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Highest 20-day momentum", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": 21.56, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": -9.52, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.76, "win_rate_pct": 40.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2023-momentum_20d-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 21.98, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 21.97, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2023", "source_period": "2023", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "vol_adjusted_momentum", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Volatility-adjusted momentum", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": 9.72, "benchmark_return_pct": 31.08, "excess_return_pct": -21.35, "mdd_pct": -8.92, "sharpe": 0.38, "win_rate_pct": 20.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 22.22, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2023-vol_adjusted_momentum-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": -0.42, "center_excess_return_pct": -31.49, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 10.14, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 10.14, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.92, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "validation_2024", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 19, "position_count": 57, "total_return_pct": 46.99, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": 63.37, "mdd_pct": -23.56, "sharpe": 1.04, "win_rate_pct": 20.75, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 45.61, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2024-short_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "validation_2024", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 19, "position_count": 57, "total_return_pct": 64.11, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": 80.48, "mdd_pct": -22.75, "sharpe": 1.3, "win_rate_pct": 20.75, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 49.12, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2024-short_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 17.12, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 17.11, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.81, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "validation_2024", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "deterministic_short", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Short deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 19, "position_count": 57, "total_return_pct": 38.27, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": 54.65, "mdd_pct": -21.75, "sharpe": 0.91, "win_rate_pct": 18.87, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 45.61, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2024-deterministic_short.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.72, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.72, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 1.81, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 37, "position_count": 111, "total_return_pct": -45.67, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": -29.3, "mdd_pct": -53.8, "sharpe": -1.52, "win_rate_pct": 26.42, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 38.74, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2024-rsi_oversold-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -92.66, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -92.67, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -30.24, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 53, "position_count": 159, "total_return_pct": -22.06, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": -5.69, "mdd_pct": -68.2, "sharpe": -0.04, "win_rate_pct": 41.51, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 40.25, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2024-rsi_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -69.05, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -69.06, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -44.64, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 16, "position_count": 48, "total_return_pct": -34.88, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": -18.5, "mdd_pct": -41.16, "sharpe": -1.95, "win_rate_pct": 9.43, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 35.42, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2024-bollinger_lower-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -81.87, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -81.87, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -17.6, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 53, "position_count": 159, "total_return_pct": 167.72, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": 184.1, "mdd_pct": -72.51, "sharpe": 1.24, "win_rate_pct": 41.51, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 38.99, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2024-bollinger_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 120.73, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 120.73, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -48.95, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "momentum_20d", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Highest 20-day momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 53, "position_count": 159, "total_return_pct": 6.97, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": 23.35, "mdd_pct": -45.73, "sharpe": 0.38, "win_rate_pct": 47.17, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 47.8, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2024-momentum_20d-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -40.02, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -40.02, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -22.17, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "vol_adjusted_momentum", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Volatility-adjusted momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 53, "position_count": 159, "total_return_pct": 24.09, "benchmark_return_pct": -16.38, "excess_return_pct": 40.47, "mdd_pct": -38.21, "sharpe": 0.66, "win_rate_pct": 52.83, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 47.8, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2024-vol_adjusted_momentum-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 46.99, "center_excess_return_pct": 63.37, "center_mdd_pct": -23.56, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -22.9, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -22.9, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -14.65, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "validation_2024", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": 0.08, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 40.4, "mdd_pct": -22.03, "sharpe": 0.08, "win_rate_pct": 16.67, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2024-long_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "validation_2024", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": -12.33, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 27.98, "mdd_pct": -27.54, "sharpe": -0.19, "win_rate_pct": 8.33, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2024-long_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -12.41, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -12.42, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -5.51, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "validation_2024", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "deterministic_long", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Long deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": 16.78, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 57.1, "mdd_pct": -9.97, "sharpe": 0.43, "win_rate_pct": 16.67, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 41.67, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs_2023_2024/runs/proof-ai-validation_2024-deterministic_long.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 16.7, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 16.7, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 12.06, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 1, "position_count": 3, "total_return_pct": 1.06, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 41.38, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.59, "win_rate_pct": 8.33, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2024-rsi_oversold-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.98, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.98, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 22.03, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": -14.31, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 26.01, "mdd_pct": -15.23, "sharpe": -0.8, "win_rate_pct": 16.67, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 25.0, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2024-rsi_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -14.39, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -14.39, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 6.8, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 3, "position_count": 9, "total_return_pct": 7.11, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 47.43, "mdd_pct": -17.27, "sharpe": 0.2, "win_rate_pct": 8.33, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2024-bollinger_lower-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 7.03, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 7.03, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 4.76, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": -5.34, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 34.97, "mdd_pct": -26.89, "sharpe": -0.0, "win_rate_pct": 8.33, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 25.0, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2024-bollinger_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -5.42, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -5.43, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -4.86, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "momentum_20d", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Highest 20-day momentum", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": 14.81, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 55.12, "mdd_pct": -3.87, "sharpe": 0.64, "win_rate_pct": 16.67, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 58.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2024-momentum_20d-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 14.73, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 14.72, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 18.16, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2024", "source_period": "2024", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "vol_adjusted_momentum", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Volatility-adjusted momentum", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": 16.02, "benchmark_return_pct": -40.32, "excess_return_pct": 56.33, "mdd_pct": -2.86, "sharpe": 0.7, "win_rate_pct": 16.67, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 58.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_long_runs_2023_2024/bt-ai-2024-vol_adjusted_momentum-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 0.08, "center_excess_return_pct": 40.4, "center_mdd_pct": -22.03, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 15.94, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 15.93, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 19.17, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "tuning_reference", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 48, "position_count": 144, "total_return_pct": 190.16, "benchmark_return_pct": 85.25, "excess_return_pct": 104.9, "mdd_pct": -34.44, "sharpe": 2.04, "win_rate_pct": 52.83, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 50.69, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-tune_2025-short_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "tuning_reference", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 48, "position_count": 144, "total_return_pct": 153.45, "benchmark_return_pct": 85.25, "excess_return_pct": 68.2, "mdd_pct": -31.83, "sharpe": 1.87, "win_rate_pct": 54.72, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 50.0, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-tune_2025-short_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -36.71, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -36.7, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 2.61, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "tuning_reference", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "deterministic_short", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Short deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 48, "position_count": 144, "total_return_pct": 216.92, "benchmark_return_pct": 85.25, "excess_return_pct": 131.67, "mdd_pct": -26.35, "sharpe": 2.31, "win_rate_pct": 52.83, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 50.69, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-tune_2025-deterministic_short.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 26.76, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 26.77, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 8.09, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 19, "position_count": 57, "total_return_pct": 16.22, "benchmark_return_pct": 85.25, "excess_return_pct": -69.03, "mdd_pct": -12.54, "sharpe": 0.78, "win_rate_pct": 16.98, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 52.63, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-tune_2025-rsi_oversold-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -173.94, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -173.93, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 21.9, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 48, "position_count": 144, "total_return_pct": 15.39, "benchmark_return_pct": 85.25, "excess_return_pct": -69.86, "mdd_pct": -34.27, "sharpe": 0.56, "win_rate_pct": 39.62, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 47.22, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-tune_2025-rsi_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -174.77, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -174.76, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.17, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 10, "position_count": 30, "total_return_pct": 10.78, "benchmark_return_pct": 85.25, "excess_return_pct": -74.47, "mdd_pct": -9.95, "sharpe": 0.6, "win_rate_pct": 11.32, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 53.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-tune_2025-bollinger_lower-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -179.38, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -179.37, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 24.49, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 48, "position_count": 144, "total_return_pct": 49.81, "benchmark_return_pct": 85.25, "excess_return_pct": -35.44, "mdd_pct": -22.37, "sharpe": 1.07, "win_rate_pct": 45.28, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 47.92, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-tune_2025-bollinger_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -140.35, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -140.34, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 12.07, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "momentum_20d", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Highest 20-day momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 53, "position_count": 159, "total_return_pct": 60.08, "benchmark_return_pct": 66.79, "excess_return_pct": -6.71, "mdd_pct": -35.98, "sharpe": 1.18, "win_rate_pct": 58.49, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 52.83, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2025-momentum_20d-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -130.08, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -111.61, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -1.54, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "vol_adjusted_momentum", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Volatility-adjusted momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 53, "position_count": 159, "total_return_pct": 34.96, "benchmark_return_pct": 66.79, "excess_return_pct": -31.83, "mdd_pct": -40.18, "sharpe": 0.89, "win_rate_pct": 49.06, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 52.83, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2025-vol_adjusted_momentum-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 190.16, "center_excess_return_pct": 104.9, "center_mdd_pct": -34.44, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -155.2, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -136.73, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -5.74, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "tuning_reference", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 103.29, "benchmark_return_pct": 110.38, "excess_return_pct": -7.1, "mdd_pct": -14.07, "sharpe": 0.76, "win_rate_pct": 50.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 54.55, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-tune_2025-long_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": 103.29, "center_excess_return_pct": -7.1, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "tuning_reference", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 71.22, "benchmark_return_pct": 110.38, "excess_return_pct": -39.16, "mdd_pct": -13.01, "sharpe": 0.63, "win_rate_pct": 41.67, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 45.45, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-tune_2025-long_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 103.29, "center_excess_return_pct": -7.1, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -32.07, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -32.06, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 1.06, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "tuning_reference", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "deterministic_long", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Long deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 82.78, "benchmark_return_pct": 110.38, "excess_return_pct": -27.6, "mdd_pct": -8.42, "sharpe": 0.96, "win_rate_pct": 50.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 48.48, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-tune_2025-deterministic_long.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 103.29, "center_excess_return_pct": -7.1, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -20.51, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -20.5, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 5.65, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 6, "position_count": 18, "total_return_pct": 33.34, "benchmark_return_pct": 110.38, "excess_return_pct": -77.04, "mdd_pct": -7.52, "sharpe": 0.65, "win_rate_pct": 25.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 61.11, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-tune_2025-rsi_oversold-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 103.29, "center_excess_return_pct": -7.1, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -69.95, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -69.94, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 6.55, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 94.71, "benchmark_return_pct": 110.38, "excess_return_pct": -15.68, "mdd_pct": -22.23, "sharpe": 0.96, "win_rate_pct": 50.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 57.58, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-tune_2025-rsi_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 103.29, "center_excess_return_pct": -7.1, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.58, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.58, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.16, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 1, "position_count": 3, "total_return_pct": -6.53, "benchmark_return_pct": 110.38, "excess_return_pct": -116.91, "mdd_pct": -6.53, "sharpe": -0.59, "win_rate_pct": 0.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-tune_2025-bollinger_lower-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 103.29, "center_excess_return_pct": -7.1, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -109.82, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -109.81, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 7.54, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2025", "source_period": "tune_2025", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 11, "position_count": 33, "total_return_pct": 92.68, "benchmark_return_pct": 110.38, "excess_return_pct": -17.7, "mdd_pct": -10.51, "sharpe": 1.12, "win_rate_pct": 66.67, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 63.64, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-tune_2025-bollinger_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 103.29, "center_excess_return_pct": -7.1, "center_mdd_pct": -14.07, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -10.61, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -10.6, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 3.56, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 14, "position_count": 42, "total_return_pct": 15.4, "benchmark_return_pct": -3.38, "excess_return_pct": 18.79, "mdd_pct": -30.59, "sharpe": 0.98, "win_rate_pct": 50.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 45.24, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-validation_2026q1-short_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "short_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Short multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 14, "position_count": 42, "total_return_pct": 18.37, "benchmark_return_pct": -3.38, "excess_return_pct": 21.75, "mdd_pct": -27.77, "sharpe": 1.07, "win_rate_pct": 50.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 47.62, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-validation_2026q1-short_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 2.97, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 2.96, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 2.82, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "deterministic_short", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Short deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 14, "position_count": 42, "total_return_pct": 24.62, "benchmark_return_pct": -3.38, "excess_return_pct": 28.01, "mdd_pct": -21.27, "sharpe": 1.54, "win_rate_pct": 57.14, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 52.38, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-validation_2026q1-deterministic_short.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 9.22, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 9.22, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 9.32, "beats_center_return": true }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 9, "position_count": 27, "total_return_pct": 8.55, "benchmark_return_pct": -3.38, "excess_return_pct": 11.93, "mdd_pct": -15.59, "sharpe": 0.9, "win_rate_pct": 35.71, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 55.56, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-rsi_oversold-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -6.85, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -6.86, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 15.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 14, "position_count": 42, "total_return_pct": -18.18, "benchmark_return_pct": -3.38, "excess_return_pct": -14.8, "mdd_pct": -31.93, "sharpe": -1.23, "win_rate_pct": 35.71, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 40.48, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-rsi_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -33.58, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -33.59, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -1.34, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 4, "position_count": 12, "total_return_pct": 4.42, "benchmark_return_pct": -3.38, "excess_return_pct": 7.8, "mdd_pct": -5.3, "sharpe": 0.87, "win_rate_pct": 21.43, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 66.67, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-bollinger_lower-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -10.98, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -10.99, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 25.29, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 14, "position_count": 42, "total_return_pct": -16.98, "benchmark_return_pct": -3.38, "excess_return_pct": -13.59, "mdd_pct": -31.54, "sharpe": -1.05, "win_rate_pct": 42.86, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 38.1, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_short/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-bollinger_ranked-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -32.38, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -32.38, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -0.95, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "momentum_20d", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Highest 20-day momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 14, "position_count": 42, "total_return_pct": -10.57, "benchmark_return_pct": -6.07, "excess_return_pct": -4.51, "mdd_pct": -35.34, "sharpe": -0.23, "win_rate_pct": 42.86, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 42.86, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2026q1-momentum_20d-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -25.97, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -23.3, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -4.75, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "short", "strategy_id": "vol_adjusted_momentum", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Volatility-adjusted momentum", "rebalance": "W", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 5, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 14, "position_count": 42, "total_return_pct": -8.04, "benchmark_return_pct": -6.07, "excess_return_pct": -1.98, "mdd_pct": -32.88, "sharpe": -0.09, "win_rate_pct": 42.86, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 45.24, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/technical_baseline_runs_2023_2026q1/bt-ai-2026q1-vol_adjusted_momentum-w-top3-h5.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "short_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 15.4, "center_excess_return_pct": 18.79, "center_mdd_pct": -30.59, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -23.44, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -20.77, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -2.29, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_hybrid_05", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_hybrid", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent hybrid", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.5, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 1, "position_count": 3, "total_return_pct": 14.2, "benchmark_return_pct": -1.94, "excess_return_pct": 16.14, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 100.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 66.67, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-validation_2026q1-long_hybrid_05.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": true, "center_total_return_pct": 14.2, "center_excess_return_pct": 16.14, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "long_llm_only", "strategy_group": "multi_agent_llm_only", "strategy_label": "Long multi-agent LLM-only", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 1.0, "llm_scope": "broad", "traded_rebalance_count": 1, "position_count": 3, "total_return_pct": 14.2, "benchmark_return_pct": -1.94, "excess_return_pct": 16.14, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 100.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 66.67, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-validation_2026q1-long_llm_only.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.2, "center_excess_return_pct": 16.14, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "validation", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "deterministic_long", "strategy_group": "deterministic", "strategy_label": "Long deterministic baseline", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 1, "position_count": 3, "total_return_pct": 6.14, "benchmark_return_pct": -1.94, "excess_return_pct": 8.08, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 100.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 33.33, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_multi_agent_runs/runs/proof-ai-validation_2026q1-deterministic_long.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.2, "center_excess_return_pct": 16.14, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.06, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -8.06, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_oversold", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "RSI(14) <= 30", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 0, "position_count": 0, "total_return_pct": 0.0, "benchmark_return_pct": -1.94, "excess_return_pct": 1.94, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 0.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "status": "completed_no_trade", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-rsi_oversold-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.2, "center_excess_return_pct": 16.14, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -14.2, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -14.2, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "rsi_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest RSI(14), no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 1, "position_count": 3, "total_return_pct": -10.13, "benchmark_return_pct": -1.94, "excess_return_pct": -8.19, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 0.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-rsi_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.2, "center_excess_return_pct": 16.14, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -24.33, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -24.33, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_lower", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Close <= Bollinger lower band", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 0, "position_count": 0, "total_return_pct": 0.0, "benchmark_return_pct": -1.94, "excess_return_pct": 1.94, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 0.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "status": "completed_no_trade", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-bollinger_lower-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.2, "center_excess_return_pct": 16.14, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -14.2, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -14.2, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false }, { "period": "2026Q1", "source_period": "validation_2026q1", "period_role": "technical_baseline", "horizon": "long", "strategy_id": "bollinger_ranked", "strategy_group": "technical", "strategy_label": "Lowest Bollinger %B, no threshold", "rebalance": "M", "top_n": 3, "hold_days": 60, "llm_weight": 0.0, "llm_scope": "", "traded_rebalance_count": 1, "position_count": 3, "total_return_pct": -8.58, "benchmark_return_pct": -1.94, "excess_return_pct": -6.64, "mdd_pct": 0.0, "sharpe": 0.0, "win_rate_pct": 0.0, "prediction_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "status": "completed", "result_json": "experiment_results/backtesting/ai_strategy_comparison/source_comparison_build/technical_long/bt-ai-validation_2026q1-bollinger_ranked-m-top3-h60.json", "center_multi_agent_strategy": "long_hybrid_05", "is_center_multi_agent": false, "center_total_return_pct": 14.2, "center_excess_return_pct": 16.14, "center_mdd_pct": 0.0, "return_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -22.78, "excess_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": -22.78, "mdd_delta_vs_center_multi_agent_pct": 0.0, "beats_center_return": false } ] }